Everything About Greer Garson -- Remember? (1939)

Click here for pictures

This movie is generally considered to be quite bad. In Time magazine's cover story on Greer in its December 20, 1943 issue, Greer's response to a query about "Remember?" is, "Let's not."
But the first half-hour of this movie is wonderful fun. If you're a fan of either Greer or Robert Taylor, you'll love it.
This movie was a hastily-made attempt to capitalize on MGM's newest sensation (Greer) and to give Robert Taylor a boost after two bombs. But "Remember?" did not succeed. Robert Taylor managed to recover the very next year with Vivien Leigh in "Waterloo Bridge", and Greer recovered with "Pride and Prejudice". And they were together again in 1941 when they blew away Joan Crawford in "When Ladies Meet".
But then "Remember?" may simply have been something that was intended to keep Greer busy until they found a really worthwhile role for her. That role came the very next year with "Pride and Prejudice."
In any case, the first half-hour or so of "Remember?" is wonderful fun. And it's full of good gags.
Lew Ayres is very funny at the beginning with the ring and his sound effects. (He was in the middle of his very successful series of Dr. Kildare movies.)
When the men meet Greer at the restaurant, Robert Taylor's banter with Greer is quite delightful. These two are great when they're together in this movie, as they are two years later in "When Ladies Meet".
And Greer gets to kiss the one and only Robert Taylor, and it's only her second movie!
Billie Burke (Greer's mother) is deliciously daft. You could fill a whole web page with the wacky lines that she gets to say. "We're having a big breakfast tomorrow. Do you like horses?"
Watch how poor Robert Taylor stands around sheepishly while the party guests stare into his eyeballs, waiting for them to change colour. He was one cool dude, and to his credit he even has the same birthday as I do.
Robert Taylor is hilarious whenever he is " startled" several times or so throughout this movie.
Greer and Bobby talk western-style before the foxhunt, and Greer attempts an American accent. She tries this again a few times in "Mrs. Parkington".
(See the second video above.)
Greer takes a golf shot out of a bunker. Elizabeth Taylor does a much better job nine years later in "Julia Misbehaves".
But I read somewhere that Greer was a golfer. Perhaps this movie inspired her to take it up.
When Greer and Bobby are riding around the 1939 World's Fair, a peacock feather blows into Greer's face and she brushes it away with her hand so that our view of her face isn't obstructed.
(See the third video above.)
Greer does a nice double-take while she's holding her breath.
The surprise-party debacle is the last really good gag in this movie. After this, the hilarity subsides for the most part.

They try to generate some comedy from the memory-loss gimmick, but with only a little success. There are some good lines but things have mostly fizzled out by then.
Near the end, Greer says to Reginald Owen "Do you know what you're saying?" It sounds just like the way she says it the very next year in "Pride and Prejudice" to Olivier during his failed proposal.
There is really never any problem to be resolved or any foe to be vanquished after the divorce. The movie just meanders along with a funny line tossed out now and then. It finally all ends with Greer uttering a line that makes absolutely no sense whatsoever.
Robert Taylor's character is the centrepiece of the movie. He's stuck in a high-pressure job and tries to make his marriage work while trying to oblige a difficult client.
Of course, it's not nice to woo your best friend's fiancée, but how do you expect Robert Taylor to resist Greer Garson?
Sorry to say, but Greer's character is the worst of the three. She's willing to marry Lew Ayres after knowing him for only two weeks, and then she's willing to marry Robert Taylor after knowing him for only a day. And she's not willing to make allowances for Robert Taylor's high-pressure job.
She's just a spoiled rich girl.

She's certainly not the perfect wife that she was in some of her later performances. She and Robert Taylor have a scene of marital bickering in this movie, and while her character's complaints in this scene may be justified, I have no doubt that Mrs. Miniver would have handled the situation in a more husband-friendly manner.
Greer acts and speaks in a very Mrs-Chip-like manner at times, with similar vocal inflections and facial mannerisms. And she over-stares at her co-actor once in a while.
But one year later she's honed her skills beautifully in "Pride and Prejudice".
All in all, this is a must-see for fans of Greer or Robert Taylor.
For others, just watch the first half-hour.